Services  /  01

The Evaluator's Red Team

Your proposal, scored the way the government will score it, while there is still time to fix what it finds.

The Problem

Internal reviews read for approval. Evaluators read for the record.

Most proposal teams review their own draft the way an approver reads: for completeness, polish, and whether every requirement is answered. A source selection board reads differently. Under FAR Part 15, evaluators score against the factors stated in Section M, and they can only credit what they can find, understand, and document as a strength, a weakness, a significant weakness, or a deficiency. A proposal can be fully compliant and still score in the middle, because compliance is the floor, not the argument.

Why it matters: by the time the government tells you how your proposal scored, the findings are final. The weaknesses an evaluator will record already exist in your draft today. The only question is whether you find them while they can still be fixed, or read them for the first time in a debrief.

Aerocore's approach

The Red Team is run under the CORE Method, principally its Assess stage. A former government source-selection evaluator reads your draft against the solicitation's stated evaluation criteria, section by section, and scores it the way a board scores it: in writing, tied to the factor, in language a consensus room could defend. This is not a proofread and not a color-team review by other proposal writers. It is the evaluation, run early.

Who it is for

Firms with a live solicitation and a draft in progress, prime contractors and subcontractors alike, who want to know how their proposal will actually score before the government tells them.

Business objective

Submit a proposal whose strengths are findable, specific, and documented, and whose deficiencies are found by you first. The objective is not a better-written proposal. It is a better-scored one.

The deliverable: an Evaluator Score Sheet and a Strengths and Deficiencies Register

You receive an Evaluator Score Sheet and a Strengths and Deficiencies Register, written the way a board writes them: every finding tied to the stated evaluation criteria, recorded as a strength, weakness, significant weakness, or deficiency, with clear revision direction your team can act on immediately.

Engagement Structure

Three structures, scoped to the proposal in front of you

Choose the structure that matches the draft you have. Scope, schedule, and fees are confirmed in a written proposal before work begins.

Structure 1

Single-Volume Review

  • One volume, up to 30 pages
  • Written findings in 3 business days
  • Scored against the stated evaluation criteria
  • Evaluator Score Sheet and Strengths and Deficiencies Register for that volume

Structure 3

Red Team Plus Debrief

  • Everything in the Full Proposal Red Team
  • A 90-minute debrief session with your team
  • A revision spot check after your fixes

Fees are set in a written proposal, based on volume count, page count, and deadline. No success fees, ever.

Have a proposal heading for submission?

Tell us the solicitation and the deadline. The review is planned backwards from your due date.

Discuss Your Requirements